PracticeProduct Judgment

Applied~2–3 minChoose, then see feedback · no writing

Which proposal gets the team?

Two roadmap bets, one team

The situation

Kelvin is a 14-person B2B analytics company. One engineering team is free next quarter and two proposals are competing for it, each written by its sponsor. The planning pack also holds the scope estimate, a cohort retention chart, the signup and spend line, and the revenue summary.

Diego · Sales: “Halverson renews in March. I need to tell them something this week.”

Both proposals are competent and honest, and the retention chart and revenue summary are in the pack. You have twenty minutes before you meet Diego and Leilani. Choose one thing to check, then commit.

What you can see (6) · tap a card to read it

›E01 · Proposal A: Salesforce integration (Diego)

Three accounts have asked in the last six weeks. Halverson Group: renewal in March, $84k ARR. Northline: in procurement, $60k proposed, and its technical evaluation lists the integration as a requirement. Bexley Analytics: an expansion conversation, currently $31k. Sales has passed on four RFPs this year that required it. Diego calls it the lowest-risk revenue work available.

›E02 · Proposal B: rebuild activation (Leilani)

New workspaces must connect a data source, define a metric and invite a teammate before the product does anything useful; session data shows a large share never complete all three, with no figure given. The rebuild pre-loads sample data, generates one starter metric and moves the invite out of the critical path. Leilani argues activation compounds across every future cohort and every acquisition dollar. She cannot promise a number.

›E03 · Scope

Proposal A: one team, most of a quarter, plus a two-week tail for the OAuth review. Diego says a read-only version would take about half that, but Northline's evaluation asks for two-way sync, so it wouldn't meet the requirement. Proposal B: one team, roughly a quarter. One team is free.

›E04 · Cohort retention, last four cohorts

Share of new workspaces still active at week N. Every workspace starts on a free 30-day trial, and most that pay convert in weeks 3–5. March: W2 61%, W4 38%, W8 19%, W12 11%. April: 58%, 35%, 17%, 9%. May: 63%, 40%, 21%, 12%. June: 60%, 36%, 18%, W12 not yet available. Four cohorts, same shape, no flattening.

›E05 · Signups and spend

Monthly new workspaces grew from 190 (March) to 340 (June). Paid acquisition spend rose from $9k to $22k per month over the same period.

›E08 · Revenue and runway

ARR $2.3m across about 160 paying accounts. Halverson is the largest account, at about 4% of ARR. Cash covers about 20 months at the current burn.

Step 1 of 2

What do you check in the twenty minutes?

Your first choice is kept. Changing your mind later counts as a retry.